Skip to content

Neil Young - Monsanto Years

9/10

by Pavlis
Neil Young - Monsanto Years

Another month, another Neil Young album... Sometimes, even the staunchest of fans must feel that Shakey needs some quality control. Given the seeming avalanche of albums, it is hardly surprising that there almost as many misses as hits. Thankfully, this is one of the hits.

For backup, Young has called upon Willie Nelson’s sons Lukas and Micah plus Lukas’s band Promise of the Real. It’s a good move.

New Day For Love, People Want To Hear and Big Box are all prime chunks of Crazy Horse. Wolf Moon is a rough 'n' ready acoustic number, like a beaten-up After The Goldrush. Rock Star Bucks manages the seemingly impossible by having whistling in a rock song and not sounding shite.

The driving garage-rockabilly-americana Workin' Man and Rules of Change’s folk-rock take on Pixies Monkey Gone To Heaven are the highlights. The slow-burning title track bears a more than passing resemblance to Roky Erikson's work with Okkervil River while If I Don't Know recalls Young’s work with Pearl Jam on Mirror Ball.

This may be Young's best album since Ragged Glory, 25 years ago. It’s certainly the most consistent. Anyone looking for an entry into the often confusing and sometimes frustrating world of Young could do far worse than look at this.

9/10

Released 30.06.15 Neil Young // Monsanto Years Reprise

Another month, another Neil Young album... Sometimes, even the staunchest of fans must feel that Shakey needs some quality control. Given the seeming avalanche of albums, it is hardly surprising that there almost as many misses as hits. Thankfully, this is one of the hits.

For backup, Young has called upon Willie Nelson’s sons Lukas and Micah plus Lukas’s band Promise of the Real. It’s a good move.

New Day For Love, People Want To Hear and Big Box are all prime chunks of Crazy Horse. Wolf Moon is a rough 'n' ready acoustic number, like a beaten-up After The Goldrush. Rock Star Bucks manages the seemingly impossible by having whistling in a rock song and not sounding shite.

The driving garage-rockabilly-americana Workin' Man and Rules of Change’s folk-rock take on Pixies This Monkey's Gone To Heaven are the highlights. The slow-burning title track bears a more than passing resemblance to Roky Erikson's work with Okkervil River while If I Don't Know recalls Young’s work with Pearl Jam on Mirror Ball.

This may be Young's best album since Ragged Glory, 25 years ago. It’s certainly the most consistent. Anyone looking for an entry into the often confusing and sometimes frustrating world of Young could do far worse than look at this.

Pavlis (9/10)

More Album Reviews

IN VENUS’ TRAIN - TAKEDA

In Venus’ Train - Takeda

Pavlis
10 Sep 2025
Kitewing

Kitewing

David Auckland
20 Feb 2024
Brown Horse - Reservoir

Brown Horse - Reservoir

Eve Wellings
21 Jan 2024

More by Pavlis

JIM JONES ALL STARS & THE MOLEE SHAKES
Live Music

Jim Jones All Stars & The Molee Shakes

Pavlis
22 Apr 2026
LANDE HEKT, APHRA & BORE JOYSEY
Live Music

Lande Hekt, Aphra & Bore Joysey

Pavlis
10 Apr 2026
NØ MAN, BIRDWITCH, GRIM HARVEST & TETHERED
Live Music

Nø Man, Birdwitch, Grim Harvest & Tethered

Pavlis
29 Mar 2026
WITCH FEVER, KNIVES & BIRDWITCH
Live Music

Witch Fever, Knives & Birdwitch

Pavlis
21 Mar 2026
NOVA TWINS, VENUS GIRLS & PRECIOUS PEPALA
Live Music

Nova Twins, Venus Girls & Precious Pepala

Pavlis
19 Mar 2026